Ex-attorney charges Toyota with destroying and withholding evidence
Ex-attorney says Toyota destroyed and withheld evidence in rollover cases
The news just got bad for Toyota Motors with the filing of a lawsuit by an ex-attorney for Toyota. Dimitrios Biller dropped a bombshell when he sued Toyota Motors Corporation in July claiming that the U.S. unit of Toyota destroyed evidence and ignored court orders to turn over electronically stored data in a number of rollover cases. According to the Complaint filed in the U.S. District Court, Central California, Toyota Motor Corporation, its U.S. subsidiaries and a number of key Toyota executives, "conspired, and continue to conspire, to unlawfully withhold evidence from plaintiffs and obstruct justice in lawsuits throughout the United States against Toyota."
Biller, who worked for Toyota from 2003 until 2007, was the former National Managing Counsel in charge of Toyota's National Rollover Program. Essentially, Biller coordinated discovery responses for Toyota in cases where it had been sued by those injured in a Toyota vehicle and claimed a rollover defect caused their injuries. Having handled these types of cases before, the argument is usually the vehicle was defectively designed because it did not protect the occupants of the vehicle during a rollover accident given the roof crushed into the passenger compartment. Many times, the roof crush results in death and/or quadriplegia/paraplegia. In the United States, there are minimum standards vehicle manufacturers must adhere to in order to protect occupants during a rollover crash.
According to Biller, when he took over his role as coordinating attorney, he found Toyota was not producing certain electronically stored information. In today's world, that is a lot of data. More disconcerting is that Toyota was ordered by a number of different state and federal courts to produce the material, but Biller alleges he was instructed not to comply with the orders. As Biller stated in his complaint, when he sought to ignore his superiors' orders not to produce the material, he was told by a superior to obey the Golden Rule--"protect the client at all cost even if that means committing illegal actions."
Now, Mr. Biller is suing for Toyota terminating his employment; however, Toyota's bigger concerns are the hundreds of cases impacted by Toyota's alleged conduct. Not surprisingly, Toyota responded to this lawsuit by seeking to seal the records. Oops. Too late. If these allegations are true, Toyota Motor Corporation is facing some huge legal problems. Many of those litigants impacted by Toyota's wrongful conduct will file lawsuits seeking to reopen the cases. Today, CBS News reported a class action lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, California, seeking to represent all plaintiffs who lost or settled cases in which Toyota allegedly concealed evidence.
There are also allegations Toyota withheld relevant data from a federal agency, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), charged with ensuring vehicles sold in the United States meets certain minimum safety standards. When the U.S. Government suggested that the standards for minimum roof crush be strengthened (FMVSS 216), it asked manufacturers for information regarding the proposed changes. Biller alleges Toyota
"withheld the original engineering report concluding that [Toyota] could start manufacturing vehicles under the standard... Instead, [Toyota] hired another engineering firm to give a second, different opinion, and that second report was provided to NHTSA. The original report never was provided and was 'buried.'"
If you or a loved one has been injured in a rollover accident, you should contat an attorney to discuss your legal rights. At the Kisselburgh Law Firm, we have experience in representing those injured by defective vehicles. Contact us online or call us at 601-936-4040.



