Tort Reform debate is a red herring in Mississippi and other states
Over the last couple months, the "Tort Reform" debate has heated up again. With Washington looking at health insurance reforms, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and their many mouthpieces are talking about the need for more tort reform. Folks, it's a red herring. The high cost of health insurance is not due to out-of-control lawsuits brought by evil plaintiff attorneys. The facts prove it.
One of the great myths perpetuated during these tort reform debates is that doctors are practicing defensive medicine because they are afraid if they don't run the test, they will be sued. This myth was busted by a number of reports showing defensive medicine is motivated more by profits for doctors who are making money when they send patients for medical imaging. The New Yorker ran a great piece about the high costs of medical care in McAllen, Texas, the Dallas Morning News reported on the increase of medical imaging in the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex and doctor discussed his first-hand experience with over-utilization as a patient.
Indicative of the myth is a great exchange between local two McAllen, Texas doctors in the New Yorker article:
"McAllen is legal hell," the cardiologist agreed. Doctors order unnecessary tests just to protect themselves, he said. Everyone thought the lawyers here were worse than elsewhere.
That explanation puzzled me. Several years ago, Texas passed a tough malpractice law that capped pain-and-suffering awards at two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. Didn't lawsuits go down? "Practically to zero," the cardiologist admitted.
"Come on," the general surgeon finally said. "We all know these arguments are bull---t. There is overutilization here, pure and simple." Doctors, he said, were racking up charges with extra tests, services, and procedures.
Another great myth perpetuated during the tort reform debate is that doctors are leaving the state due to out of control lawsuits. This was a big one used by Mississippi's governor. However, facts prove otherwise. A recent article reported there was no decrease in the number of doctors in Mississippi. It stated, "Information compiled by the American Medical Association ... shows that the number of physicians in Mississippi rose steadily in years leading up to tort-reform legislation in 2004, and even slowed its increased following 2004."
So let's put the "tort reform" punching bag away and get down to studying the true problems of our health care system and the need for reform.
h/t: ThePopTort.com has a number of articles on this issue at here, here, here, and here.
Information provided by Robert Kisselburgh, Mississippi Accident Injury Attorney
